2026 Staffing Budget
$4.6M
Salaries + contracted services
% of Total Budget
57%
⚠ At ceiling · Comparable churches avg. ≤55%
Total Budget (2026)
$7.4M
Assumes $8.1M in giving
2027 Full Realization
$4.8M
59% · All hires fully annualized
Budget allocation vs. benchmarks
2026 Budget Allocation
$7.4M total · Proposed distribution
$7.4M
Total
Staffing Trend 2025–2027
Staffing & contracted services as % of budget · Comparable churches avg. ≤55%
Caution — at the ceiling. At 57% in 2026 rising to 59% in 2027, RSF is within 1–3% of the upper threshold and above the ≤55% average of comparable churches. To create capacity for future strategic hires and to advance the mission more effectively, leadership should evaluate staff reductions and role reassignments. A review of roles and responsibilities may surface opportunities to consolidate or restructure positions — freeing margin for higher-impact ministry investment.
Ideal vs. Current Allocation
Progress bars show current 2026 position vs. target ranges
Adjust assumptions
Total Giving / Revenue
$8.1M annual
$6M$10M
Total Staffing + Contracted
$4.6M annual
$3M$6M
Ministry Operations Budget
$2.4M annual
$500K$4M
Facilities Budget
$740K annual
$300K$2M
Tithe / Missions Giving
$518K annual
$100K$2M
Additional Hires
0 additional hires
0123
e.g. Church Planting Candidate or assuming giving outpaces budget
Model output
⚠ Staffing at 57% — within 1–3% of ceiling · Comparable churches avg. ≤55%
Allocation Breakdown
Live chart tied to sliders above
Benchmark Status
2026 New hire timeline
Hire Sequencing & Salary Impact
2026 partial realization $400K · Full annualization in 2027: $555K
Margaret Hong
Executive Assistant
Nov '25
Heather Casimere
Pastoral Resident
Feb '26
Sam Roberson
Connections Director
Mar '26
Development Director
Campaign Lead
Q1 '26
Tim Chaddick
Formation Pastor
Jul '26
*Heather Casimere salary 50% offset by MTF Grant (Made to Flourish) · Limited to 2-year term
***Development Director required for upcoming capital campaign · Limited to 3-year term
New Hire Detail & Cost Analysis
% of full-year salary realized in 2026 · Net of grants where applicable
Name / Role Start 2026 Months 2026 % Realized Grant Offset Net % to RSF Status
Margaret Hong
Executive Assistant
Nov '25 12 mos 100% 100% Active
Heather Casimere
Pastoral Resident · MTF Grant
Feb '26 11 mos 92% 50% (MTF) 46% Active
Sam Roberson
Connections Director
Mar '26 10 mos 83% 83% Active
Development Director
Campaign Lead · 3yr term
Q1 '26 ~9 mos 75% 75% Pending
Tim Chaddick
Formation Pastor
Jul '26 6 mos 50% 50% Board Approved
Church-Planting Candidate
Optional · Pushes to 60% threshold
TBD ~50% ~50% Optional
2026 Partial Total ~$383,333 net of grants
Salary Realization: 2026 vs 2027
% of full-year salary realized per hire
Staffing % Trajectory
With and without church-planting candidate
Central Leadership Team
Staffing & Budget Benchmark Brief
May 2026 · Prepared by Finance & Operations
For internal distribution
Not for public release

1
Where We Are
The board of trustees has approved a $7.4 million budget for 2026, anchored by a projected giving base of $8.1 million. Of this, $4.6 million (57%) is allocated to staffing and contracted services — a meaningful increase from $4.3 million (52%) in 2025, driven by the strategic addition of five new positions throughout the year.
2026 Staffing Load: $4.6M · 57% of budget
Ministry Operations: $2.4M · 33% of budget
Facilities: $740K · 10% of budget
This staffing increase reflects a deliberate investment in ministry infrastructure — specifically in Formation, Connections, and Development leadership — which positions RSF for sustained ministry health and the upcoming capital campaign.

2
The Benchmark
Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability (ECFA) and independent church consulting research consistently identify 50–55% as the healthy range for staffing and contracted services as a percentage of total operating budget. Major metropolitan cities occasionally surpass this threshold due to cost of living or other factors. Exceeding the 55% threshold should be carefully considered, as it could severely limit the church's ability to carry out ministry. 60% and above creates structural fragility — any giving shortfall translates directly into personnel decisions.
Best Practice Target: 50%–60% staffing as a share of budget
2025 Actual: 52% — well within range
2026 Projected: 57% — within range, approaching upper threshold
2027 Full Realization: 59% — at the ceiling, no additional capacity
The 2026 figure of 57% reflects partial-year costs for hires made throughout the calendar year. When all five new positions are fully annualized in 2027, total staffing rises to approximately $4.8 million (59%) — still within range, but with no room for additional hires without a corresponding increase in giving.

3
The New Hires
Five new positions are part of the 2026 staffing plan. Due to the timing of hires across the year, 2026 reflects a partial-year cost of approximately $400K, with full annualization reaching $555K in 2027.

Margaret Hong (Nov '25) — Executive Assistant
Full year realized in 2026. Provides senior operational support across the executive function.

Heather Casimere (Feb '26) — Pastoral Resident
50% of salary offset by the Made to Flourish (MTF) Grant, reducing net cost to RSF. Limited to a 2-year term.

Sam Roberson (Mar '26) — Connections Director
Directly addresses the strategic priority of congregational connection and integration.

Development Director (Q1 '26)
Required for the upcoming capital campaign. Contracted as a 3-year term position.

Tim Chaddick (Jul '26) — Formation Pastor
The most significant single hire, beginning July. Full-year impact begins in 2027 and is included in board-approved staffing projections.

4
The Church-Planting Decision
An optional church-planting candidate is under consideration. Adding this role would increase total staffing, pushing the 2026 staffing ratio from 57% to approximately 58–60% — exceeding best-practice levels and the upper end of trustee board guidance.
Decision point: Hiring the church-planting candidate in 2026 is financially feasible, but it eliminates all remaining headroom.
Beyond the budget ratio, RSF is relatively staff-heavy by a second measure: the ratio of staff to congregation size. Both ECFA guidance and Hammer's 2025 Church Salaries & Staffing Guide identify staff-to-congregant ratios as a parallel indicator of organizational health — and by this metric, RSF's staffing density warrants the same careful diligence as the salary-to-budget ratio. The recommendation is to consider staff reductions and role reassignments as a means of creating capacity for future strategic hires and redirecting resources toward higher-impact ministry. If giving goals are not met or a market downturn reduces giving, staff reductions would likely become necessary.

5
Ideal Distribution & Forward Posture
Finance and Operations recommends the following as the long-term target allocation framework for RSF's operating budget:

Staffing & Contracted Services: 50–60% — current position is healthy. No new permanent positions should be added in 2026 beyond those already approved without a corresponding giving increase or a term-limited structure.

Ministry Operations: 15–20% — currently at 33%, which reflects our investment in program delivery, events, and care. This is above target and warrants ongoing review as staffing fully matures.

Facilities: 10–15% — currently at 10%, within the ideal range. Building initiatives are funded separately through capital campaign proceeds and should not be drawn from the operating budget.

Tithe / Missions: 10–15% — currently at approximately 7%. This is below the recommended level and reflects a prioritization of ministry build-out. Finance recommends a phased increase as giving grows.

This brief was prepared by the Finance & Operations team for internal distribution to the Central Leadership Team. All figures reflect board-approved 2026 budget allocations. Questions should be directed to the Administration & Finance Pastor.
Reality San Francisco · Finance & Operations · Confidential · 2026